I ran some database queries this morning to get a list of all players who have been in the top 5 for their faction for each Atlantis in the past year. Here is the list with a count of how many Atlantis battles included their name in the top 5. Enjoy.
Polarbear 12
Intmadatrs 11
Kerik 11
soupist 11
FloppyDrive 10
JBo 9
KALKIN 8
LT_Smash 6
surris 5
Artz 4
bigE 4
kornpop 4
Tarn 4
Alt3r3dstate 3
DaisyDragon 3
DevonianTeuchter 3
ItsBigAl 3
LordCosta 3
Recons_Mom 3
roosterman 3
T3nax 3
AmberElk63 2
Aslaug 2
BigDaddyChuck 2
Cesium 2
gman5280 2
GuardShot 2
klnspl 2
nateweger 2
omega3 2
phrozt 2
Volwez 2
__Bahamut__ 1
AgentConDier 1
ali3n 1
Ambr0sia 1
Andrea_Doria 1
Balo 1
Barf 1
bozo 1
Byron34 1
Devangel 1
Dragonleada 1
fackinace 1
FE2O3E 1
Fedarts 1
forestman 1
guydovich 1
Haimai 1
Hammerhead_Shark 1
Humhead 1
Hussar 1
Kizah 1
ktomasz 1
legionellahal 1
lochmere 1
NeonBuffalo11 1
NineTailedFoxx 1
OwlEye 1
PandaBear6 1
Peaky_Blinder 1
sassyrascal 1
stuff 1
tedly 1
Tyro1 1
Um1b1 1
WizardNx 1